Sunset Beach, Shelter Island — from $596

58 photos

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Amenities photo

Sunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photo

Book on our site

up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965

Next to the idyllic beach

Great

8.2

8.7

/10

3.8

3.5

4-star beachfront hotel in Shelter Island

Location

Sunset Beach is situated along 500 feet of private sandy beach on Shelter Island. The hotel provides direct access to the picturesque bay for memorable water activities. Guests can enjoy close proximity to Sunset Beach's scenic landscape, perfect for beachside strolls and outdoor exploration.

Dining

The hotel offers a beachfront restaurant featuring a menu of seasonal, locally-sourced dishes. Guests can enjoy dining options that showcase regional ingredients with a focus on fresh seafood. Sunset Beach also has a casual outdoor bar serving refreshing drinks with beautiful bay views.

Rooms

Sunset Beach provides a range of room types, each offering comfortable accommodations overlooking the bay or gardens. All rooms include private balconies or patios for outdoor relaxation. Guests can find suites equipped with kitchenettes for a home-like experience during their stay.

Wellness

The hotel is dedicated to wellness with a selection of outdoor yoga classes available to guests. Families can benefit from the beachside activities designed for both relaxation and fun. The hotel encourages guests to stay active with paddleboarding and kayaking options right at the beach.

Family-Friendly Amenities

Sunset Beach accommodates families with a range of activities suitable for children. The hotel offers organized beach games and crafts to engage younger guests. Cribs and rollaway beds are available upon request, adding convenience for families traveling with infants or small children.

Highlights

Location: 500 feet of private sandy beach

Dining: beachfront restaurant featuring seasonal dishes

Rooms: private balconies with bay views

Wellness: outdoor yoga classes available

Must-do experiences

Rent a kayak at Sunset Beach for a fun day on the water.
Try the famous lobster rolls at The Sunset Grill nearby.
Stroll through the charming Shelter Island Farmers Market on Saturdays.
Visit the Shelter Island Historical Society for local culture.
Catch a sunset at Sunset Beach Bar; it's breathtaking!

View all

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

Sunset Beach offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

General

Wi-Fi
Smoke detectors

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area

Room features

Dressing area
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Hair dryer

Media

Flat-screen TV
Direct dial telephone
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Sunset Beach Location

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965

Map view

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States, 11965

City landmarks

Landmark

Shelter Island Country Club

2300 ft

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

2400 ft

Landmark

Shelter Island Tennis Club

3000 ft

Event hall

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

1.4 mi

Church

Our Lady of the Isle Church

4000 ft

Landmark

Dering Harbor Marina

1.4 mi

Amusement Park

Greenport Antique Carousel

2.0 mi

Island

Shelter Island

1.5 mi

Landmark

Sylvester Manor

1.4 mi

Landmark

Fireboat Firefighter Museum

1.8 mi

Landmark

Railroad Museum of Long Island

1.8 mi

Landmark

Congregation Tifereth Israel

1.9 mi

Market

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

1.4 mi

Museum

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation

1.8 mi

Landmark

Camera Obscura

1.9 mi

Landmark

East End Seaport Maritime Museum

2.1 mi

Church

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

1.5 mi

Gallery

Nova Constellatio Gallery

2.1 mi

Landmark

Shelter Island Kayak

1.6 mi

Harbour

Greenport

2.1 mi

Landmark

Manhansett Chapel Museum

1.7 mi

Landmark

Peconic Water Sports

1.7 mi

Landmark

Fire Fighter Ship New York

1.8 mi

Landmark

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

1.8 mi

Church

Saint Marys Episcopal Church

1.8 mi

Landmark

Shelter Island Tennis

1.8 mi

Landmark

Long Island Train Museam

1.8 mi

Nearby

Sunset Beach

800 ft

Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals

1100 ft

Beach

Crescent Beach

1800 ft

Restaurants

The Pridwin Restaurant

3000 ft

81 Shore Road

Explore Shelter Island

Experience Sunset Beach

Shelter Island Country Club

10 minutes' walk

Golfing paradise featuring scenic views and well-maintained greens. Ideal for both novice and experienced golfers.

Shelter Island Tennis Club

10 minutes' walk

A beautiful tennis venue offering courts for casual and competitive play. A fun way to enjoy the outdoors.

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

4 minutes' drive

Historic farm with tours, educational programs, and a farm stand. Unique opportunity to learn about local agriculture.

Discover the local attractions near Sunset Beach

Experience local attractions near Sunset Beach that highlight the rich history and culture of Shelter Island

Ideal for history enthusiasts: Railroad Museum of Long Island

Great for a glimpse into the past: Havens House

Best for learning about firefighting history: Fireboat Firefighter Museum

Well suited for art lovers: Nova Constellatio Gallery

Perfect for nature lovers and education: Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

Suited for a nostalgic family experience: Greenport Antique Carousel

Great for contemporary art enthusiasts: VSOP Art + Design Projects

Works well for scenic coastal walks: Greenport

Kayaking at Sunset Beach

3 minutes' walk

Kayaking rental available to enjoy the serene waters. Perfect for both relaxing or exciting explorations.

Hiking at Mashomack Preserve

10 minutes' drive

Wonderful trails through diverse ecosystems. Ideal for nature lovers and those looking for a peaceful escape.

The Pridwin Restaurant

11 minutes' walk

Charming atmosphere with farm-to-table dishes. Enjoy fresh seafood and local ingredients overlooking the bay.

Sunset Beach Restaurant

3 minutes' walk

Casual beachside dining with a vibrant atmosphere. Known for fresh cocktails and island-inspired cuisine.

Discover dining options near Sunset Beach

Savor delightful dining options near Sunset Beach that offer a taste of local cuisine

Perfect for casual dining with local flavors: Shelter Island House

Dering Harbor Marina

10 minutes' drive

Marina with various boat tours and fishing opportunities. A great spot for boating enthusiasts and families alike.

Live Music at Sunset Beach

3 minutes' walk

Enjoy live music events regularly. A lively spot perfect for relaxing evenings with friends and family.

Getting around

City Centre

Shelter Island2 min · 400 ft

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP)127 min · 52.5 mi

Republic (FRG)170 min · 70.2 mi

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 16:00-23:59

Check-out

until 11 am

Guest Parking

Public parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.

Breakfast

A full breakfast is served and charges are applicable.

Children & extra beds

One child: 0 - 2 years

Cot: FREE

Existing beds: FREE

One child: 3 - 17 years

Existing beds: FREE

Extra bed: us$ 100

Children above
17 years or adults:

Extra bed: us$ 100

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Year renovated:

2010

Number of rooms:

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Sunset Beach from previous guests about their experience.

Review score

Based on 43 verified reviews

8.3/10

Great

74%

Recommend

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

FAQs

About Sunset Beach

How far is Sunset Beach from Long Island MacArthur Airport?

Sunset Beach is 100 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport.

What are the check-in and check-out times at Sunset Beach?

Check-in time is 16:00 and check-out time is 11:00.

What dining options are available at Sunset Beach?

Sunset Beach features an on-site restaurant serving French cuisine and a full-service bar.

Is there a beach accessible to guests at Sunset Beach?

Guests can enjoy exclusive access to a private beach.

What room amenities are provided at Sunset Beach?

Rooms are equipped with climate control, a flat-screen TV, and an iPod docking station.

Does Sunset Beach allow pets?

Sunset Beach is a pet-friendly property and offers grooming services.

How close is Sunset Beach to Crescent Beach?

Crescent Beach is located 2 km away from Sunset Beach.

What wellness services are offered at Sunset Beach?

Yoga sessions and in-room massages are available for guests at Sunset Beach.

Are there any nearby attractions to Sunset Beach?

Popular nearby attractions include the Greenport Antique Carousel, located 4 km away.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.

Beach Plum Resort

Montauk, United States

8.851 reviews

215 US$/night

Sun And Sound Montauk

Montauk, United States

9.054 reviews

189 US$/night

The Atlantic

Southampton, United States

6.389 reviews

119 US$/night

Southampton Inn

Southampton, United States

8.372 reviews

665 US$/night

Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead

Riverhead, United States

9.1101 reviews

184 US$/night

Residence Inn By Marriott New York Long Island East End

Riverhead, United States

8.660 reviews

262 US$/night

Springhill Suites Long Island Brookhaven

Bellport, United States

8.2111 reviews

111 US$/night

Danfords Hotel & Marina

Port Jefferson, United States

7.9120 reviews

129 US$/night

Courtyard By Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Central Islip, United States

8.251 reviews

187 US$/night

Nolitan Hotel Soho - New York

New York, United States

7.9346 reviews

155 US$/night

Red Lion Inn & Suites Long Island City

New York, United States

6.7283 reviews

91 US$/night

The Brook At Turning Stone

Verona, United States

5.020 reviews

65 US$/night

Popular hotels all over the world

Find your perfect hotel stay today

8.5/1062 reviews

Hilton Vacation Club Riviera Beach & Shores

Riviera Beach Resort Capistrano Beach Ca

Dana Point, United States

Steps from Capistrano Beach, Suites with full kitchens

View hotel

7.3/10525 reviews

Clinton Hotel South Beach

Miami Beach, United States

Steps to private beach, Limonada Bar + Brunch

View hotel

8.4/10137 reviews

Hotel Maren Fort Lauderdale Beach, Curio Collection By Hilton

Hotel Maren Fort Lauderdale Reviews

Fort Lauderdale, United States

Steps from Las Olas Beach, Ocean views from 5th-floor pool deck

View hotel

Holiday Inn New Orleans French Quarter

10-minute walk to Bourbon Street, Courtyard with heated saltwater pool

La Quinta Inn & Suites By Wyndham New Orleans Downtown Hotel Us-New-orleans.us

Steps from the French Quarter, Rooftop pool

Newbury Guest House Hotel

Historic brownstone district location, 35 well-appointed guestrooms

Western Isles Hotel

Dog-friendly rooms and public spaces, Sea view rooms from 17 to 50 m²

Flodigarry Hotel

Sea views towards the Torridons, Country house on a hill

The Falcon Inn — Visit website

11 bespoke bedrooms, The Cotswolds Way access

The Old Success Inn Sennen Cove Hotel

Dog friendly rooms available, Ocean views

Hotel Hilton Garden Inn Billings Yegen

13 km from Billings Logan International Airport, Indoor swimming pool

Hilton 56th Street Nyc

Opposite Museum of Modern Art, 2 km from Central Park